In the realm of cinema, the latest offering, 'Citizen Vigilante,' has sparked a conversation about the intersection of art, politics, and the far-right. This Uwe Boll film, starring Armie Hammer, presents a unique and controversial narrative that begs for analysis and interpretation.
The Vigilante's Fantasy
The film's protagonist, Michael Sanders, embodies a complex figure. He's an American expat, a landlord, and a self-appointed vigilante, taking matters into his own hands in a European city plagued by what he perceives as migrant-related crime. The character's dual role as a landlord and a violent do-gooder is an intriguing choice, one that adds a layer of complexity to the typical vigilante fantasy.
A Tale of Petulance
What makes 'Citizen Vigilante' particularly fascinating is its portrayal of a petulant culture. The film's opening sequence, with its gruesome stabbing and exaggerated portrayal of migrants, sets the tone for a narrative that seems to thrive on provoking a specific audience. It's a story that feeds into the fears and frustrations of a certain demographic, offering a simplistic and violent solution to complex social issues.
The Lack of Cohesion
One of the most striking aspects of the film is its lack of ideological coherence. Sanders, the vigilante, cannot be easily categorized as an anarchist or a fascist. He wants to profit from the capitalist system while simultaneously tearing it down. This character study, or lack thereof, raises questions about the film's true intentions and its place within the conservative art movement.
Conservative Art: A Misunderstood Concept
There's a prevalent misconception that conservative art is inherently bad or non-existent. However, history proves otherwise. From action-packed Michael Bay films like 'Bad Boys 2' to the works of David Mamet and Tyler Perry, conservative themes have found expression in various art forms. The idea that conservatism stifles creativity is a narrative that needs challenging.
The Rise of Petulance
The election of Trump in 2024 seemed to signal a new era of conservative dominance. But what emerged was a culture of petulance, characterized by online influencers using derogatory slurs and the rise of controversial figures like Nick Fuentes. This petulance is evident in various forms of media, from stand-up comedy to news media, and even in the world of streaming and podcasts.
Petulance on the Big Screen
'Citizen Vigilante' is part of a wave of films that seem to capitalize on this petulant culture. These films, including 'Lady Ballers' and the upcoming Jonathan Majors vehicle, appear to be more about provoking a reaction than offering a coherent ideological message. They are cultural trolls, designed to stir up controversy and appeal to a specific audience.
The Importance of Craftsmanship
Despite its provocative nature, 'Citizen Vigilante' fails to make a significant impact due to its poor execution. The film lacks depth, with plot threads left unresolved and characters lacking complexity. It's a prime example of how a lack of craftsmanship can undermine even the most controversial of storylines.
A Comparison with Abel Ferrara
In contrast, a director like Abel Ferrara, known for his violent urban crime films, brings a level of moral complexity to his work. His films, like 'Bad Lieutenant,' explore themes of vengeance and justice without preaching. This depth of exploration is what sets apart a thought-provoking film from a mere provocation.
The Offensive Conclusion
The film's final act, involving the murder of a Muslim family, is highly offensive and reinforces stereotypes. However, the film's poor execution and lack of ideological depth make it difficult to take seriously as a piece of propaganda. It's more akin to a Bill Maher rant or an Elon Musk tweet brought to life through gunplay.
The Future of Political Cinema
With the rise of leftist political movements, one can't help but wonder if the future of political cinema lies in exploring these complex ideologies. The hope is that any films emerging from this wave will be crafted with the skill and depth that the medium deserves.
In conclusion, 'Citizen Vigilante' serves as a reminder that art, especially when it ventures into controversial territory, must be executed with care and craftsmanship to leave a lasting impact.
